The stock market has been exceptionally volatile in recent weeks, with investors facing uncertainty amidst disappointing earnings reports from major technology companies, unexpected macroeconomic data, and geopolitical tensions, including the possibility of a multi-arena conflict in Israel. As a result, global indices have seen sharp declines, including those in Israel, leading many investors to confront a significant dilemma: Should they sell their falling stocks or hold onto them in hopes of a rebound?

The psychological toll of watching stocks plummet can lead to hasty decisions fueled by fear and emotion. This emotional response can detract from the quality of investment decisions, particularly when investors develop an attachment to a particular stock. According to analysts, a decline in stock value alone isn’t necessarily a reason to sell. Instead, it might be an opportunity to reassess the overall portfolio and the underlying reasons for the decline.

When a stock you own falls, it’s crucial to identify the cause. If the decline is due to a fundamental shift that undermines the original investment thesis – such as deteriorating business conditions or a significant change in the company’s strategy – it may be wise to cut losses. Conversely, if the drop is due to market distortions or external pressures that don’t reflect the company’s long-term prospects, it might be better to hold or even increase your position.

Investors should ask themselves whether the company’s fundamentals have worsened, whether its competitive environment has changed, or if there has been a strategic misstep. If the core business remains strong, selling might not be necessary.

Also, it’s essential to distinguish between a stock falling due to company-specific issues – such as a profit warning – or because of broader market conditions. If the entire market is down and your stock is simply more volatile, it might be best to stay the course, particularly if you believe in the company’s long-term resilience.

However, if the sector as a whole is declining or the company has failed to meet its forecasts – such as struggling to enter new markets or realize its technological vision—this could indicate a more serious, structural issue. In such cases, reassessing your investment is critical.

Another way of reassessing your portfolio holding is to ask yourself is whether, given the current market conditions and the new information at hand, you would buy the stock today. If the answer is no, it might be time to consider selling, even if it means accepting a loss.

This approach encourages a fresh perspective on the stock’s potential, independent of the emotional attachment that can come with being an existing shareholder. If you wouldn’t invest in the stock today, holding onto it might not be the best strategy.

Deciding whether to sell or hold a falling stock is a challenging decision that requires careful consideration of both external market conditions and the specific factors affecting the stock. By asking the right questions and keeping emotions in check, investors can make more informed decisions that align with their long-term financial goals.

Image: freepik.com